Waiting Encounters: The Courage to Teach

Academic institutions offer myriad ways to protect ourselves from the threat of the live encounter. To avoid a live encounter with teachers, students can hide behind their notebooks and their silence. To avoid a live encounter with students, teacher can hide behind their podiums, their credentials, their power. To avoid a live encounter with one another, faculty can hide behind their academic specialties.

To avoid a live encounter with subject of study, teachers and students alike can hide behind the pretense of objectivity: students can say, “Don’t ask me to think about this stuff – just give me the facts,” and faculty can say, “Here are the facts – don’t think about them, just get them straight.” To avoid a live encounter with ourselves, we can learn the art of self-alienation, of living a divided life.

This fear of the live encounter is actually a sequence of fears that begins in the fear of diversity. As long as we inhabit a universe made homogeneous by our refusal to admit otherness, we can maintain the illusion that we possess the truth about ourselves and the world – after all, there is no “other” to challenge us! But as soon as we admit pluralism, we are forced to admit that ours is not the only standpoint, the only experience, the only way, and the truths we have build our lives and begin to feel fragile.

If we embrace diversity, we find ourselves on the doorstep of our next fear; fear of the conflict that will ensure when divergent truths meet. Because academic culture knows only one form of conflict, the win-lose form called competition, we fear the live encounter as a contest from which one party emerges victorious while the other leaves defeated and ashamed. To evade public engagement over our dangerous differences, we privatize them, only to find them growing larger and more divisive.

If we peel back our fear of conflict, we find a third layer of fear, the fear of losing identity. Many of us are so deeply identified with our ideas that when we have a competitive encounter, we risk losing more than the debate: we risk losing our sense of self.

Of course, there are forms of conflict more creative than the win-lose form called competition, forms that are vital if the self is to grow. But academic culture knows little of these alternative forms – such as consensual decision making – in which all can win and none need lose, in which “winning” means emerging from the encounter with a larger sense of self than one brought int it, in which we learn that the self is not a scrap of turf to be defended but a capacity to be enlarged.

“If we embrace the promise of diversity, of creative conflict, and of “losing” in order to “win,” we still face one final fear – the fear that a live encounter with otherness will challenge or even compel us to change our lives.

Otherness taken seriously, always invites transformation, calling us not only to new facts and theories and values but also to new ways of living our lives – and that is, the most daunting threat of all.”

Similar Posts

  • If You Were Me and I WAS YOU

    We spend our lives locked inside our own skin, looking out through the narrow window of our own assumptions and predispositions. In their 1993 collaboration “If You Were Me,” Elton John and Chris Rea deliver a radical, beautiful challenge to this isolation: What if we could step out of our own stories and inhabit the soul of another? Two empty chairs sit side by side on the album cover, a quiet but fierce provocation. They do not represent a permanent absence; they are an open invitation. One seat is yours. The other belongs to the person you have yet to understand. The melody has ended, and the furniture is waiting. The question is no longer whether we can hear the song, but whether we have the courage to cross the room and sit down.

  • “Imagine the Angels of Bread” by Martín Espada

    “Martín Espada’s Imagine the Angels of Bread is a fascinating blend of anger and compassion, horror and dream. The speaker imagines a worldwide release from oppression through a series of near-apocalyptic revolutionary reversals—inverting long-standing injustices by dreaming of liberating the poor and the victims of discrimination.”— Heather Zadra, Modern American Poetry Society

  • Mens InSana In Corpore InSano: The Broken Soul of Modern Athletics

    Mens sana in corpore sano—a sound mind in a sound body. While this ideal anchors modern sports, the reality is often marred by institutional corruption and systemic abuse. We channel infinite energy into athletic arenas while treating the preservation of our society as an afterthought. To secure our future, we must redirect this fanaticism—cheering for diversity, equity, social justice, rule of law with the same daily devotion we give to March Madness. Sports will always be a celebrated thread in our cultural tapestry, but it is time to champion citizenship and democracy with the exact same passion, energy, and uncompromising dedication we bring to the stadium.

  • Polio ~ Anti-Semitism Almost Denied Its Cure

    During the early-to-mid-20th century, poliomyelitis raged as a relentless global pandemic with no known cure, entirely unstoppable until the advent of preventative vaccination. But while communities isolated themselves to escape the virus, an equally destructive set of social diseases—racism, sexism, xenophobia, and anti-Semitism—was quietly infecting the very fabric of American citizenship. This intersection of medical panic and deep-seated social prejudice creates a troublesome reality to ponder regarding how the life-saving polio vaccine came to be. The irony is sharp and bitter: the breakthrough was nearly denied by the very culture that stood to benefit from it the most. Dr. Jonas Salk himself had to scale systemic anti-Semitic barriers just to enter the medical field, routinely facing strict university admission quotas designed explicitly to limit Jewish students. Despite these institutional hurdles, Dr. Salk and Dr. Albert Sabin persisted, ultimately offering a love without boundaries. They did not develop their vaccines to save only Jewish children—they sought to heal all of humanity. Tragically, many who received that life-saving grace were the very people who remained inherently incapable of reciprocating that love due to their deeply ingrained pathologies

  • What It Means to be White ~ Inclusive Programming Part II of II by Adam Collins

    For a young educator in his fifth year, everyday tasks like selecting ensemble music often highlight systemic gaps in training, influenced by time constraints and catalog visibility. Adam Collins shares his personal realization regarding disparities in race and gender within music composition and how online distributor browsing habits shape choices, noting how he previously joked about titling pieces alphabetically to secure top placement.

  • A Ritual to Read to Each Other

    William Stafford had a quiet daily ritual of writing focusing on the ordinary.
    His poetic style seems to invite a conversation that is close to everyday speech to remain alert and ‘awake’ for there is many a small betrayal in the wind.
    “I call it cruel and maybe the root of all cruelty to know what occurs but not recognize the fact.”

    William Stafford, “A Ritual to Read to Each Other” from The Way It Is: New and Selected Poems. Copyright © 1998 by William Stafford.